Choosing Between Home Cooked and Raw Diets for Dogs

Many pet owners consider home-cooked or raw diets, yet the complexities and disagreements persist.  The allure of home-cooked or raw diets for dogs sparks interest, but the challenge lies in creating a well-balanced and safe regimen. With conflicting opinions on the ideal pet diet, a nuanced approach becomes crucial. This comprehensive guide navigates through the intricacies, highlighting the importance of informed decisions and professional guidance.

What is raw pet food?Raw pet food refers to a category of pet food that contains uncooked or minimally processed ingredients, primarily sourced from animals. Unlike traditional commercial pet foods, which are often heat-processed or cooked, raw pet food retains its raw and natural state. Common ingredients in raw pet food include:

  1. Uncooked Muscle Meat: Such as thigh and breast meat.
  2. Uncooked Organ Meat: Like liver and kidney.
  3. Uncooked Bones: Providing a natural source of calcium.
  4. Uncooked Eggs: Adding protein and nutrients.
  5. Unpasteurized Milk: Although this is not recommended due to potential health risks, it is sometimes included.

Raw pet food comes in various forms, including raw (similar to raw meat purchased at the grocery store), raw frozen, freeze-dried (frozen and then dried in a vacuum), and dehydrated (dried using warm air). Treats and food toppers, such as rawhide chews and freeze-dried treats, can also fall into the category of raw pet food.

Consulting with Veterinarians:
Embarking on a home-cooked or raw diet requires meticulous planning. Consultation with a veterinarian is paramount, and a referral to a veterinary nutritionist may be recommended. These specialists help tailor diets to meet specific health needs, ensuring a nutritionally complete balance of calories, protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals.

AVMA's Cautionary Recommendations:
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) underscores the risks associated with feeding untreated animal-source protein to cats and dogs. Their recommendation includes avoiding such protein, restricting access to carrion, and promoting the provision of nutritionally balanced commercial or home-cooked food while maintaining personal hygiene.

Raw Pet Food Composition:
Understanding the composition of raw pet food is essential. This category includes uncooked muscle and organ meat, bones, eggs, and unpasteurized milk. Available in various forms, such as raw, raw frozen, freeze-dried, and dehydrated, even treats and toppers fall under this classification.

CDC's Stance on Raw Pet Food:
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advises against feeding raw pet food due to potential bacterial contamination, including Salmonella and Listeria. Contrary to popular belief, raw pet food doesn't guarantee enhanced health and nutrition compared to cooked alternatives.

Considerations for Raw Diets:
For those considering a raw diet, consulting with veterinarians becomes imperative. Key considerations include household health vulnerabilities, pet susceptibility, diet completeness, and the ability to maintain cleanliness. Purchasing from reputable companies with stringent safety measures is advised.

Safety Practices for Raw Pet Food:
Maintaining hygiene is crucial when handling raw pet food. This involves frequent handwashing, cleaning items and surfaces that come into contact with raw food, and proper chilling and storage practices. Companies adhering to high food safety standards should be prioritised.

Choosing between home-cooked and raw diets requires thoughtful consideration. While both options have merits, the emphasis is on responsible choices, guided by veterinary professionals, and a commitment to the health and well-being of pets.

Genevieve Tan

January 8, 2024
Read More Articles
Help build a nationwide canine blood registry
Join Bark Bank as a canine blood donor and offer a helping paw to those in need. Your dog has the potential to be a lifesaver, bringing hope to others facing health challenges.
Register
Connect with us:
Email iconInstaagram iconFacebook icon